It is a relaxation on the traditional rule of locus standi. Public interest litigation though the theory of public interest litigation hereafter referred as pil is the result of judicial activism, it raises up as efficient way of the higher judiciary to entertain judicial activism. The concept of public interest litigation pil always made when judicial activism discussed. Jul 10, 2020 pil and judicial activism go hand in hand. Concourt has been ending on technical arguments in public interest litigation pil cases. Mar 24, 2017 t he term judicial activism was coined for the first time by arthur schlesinger jr in his article the supreme court. Public interest litigation and judicial activism pen acclaims. Would you like to get the full thesis from shodh ganga along with citation details. Amongst glaring problems in a diverse society, the vision of nationbuilding has marched strongly on bedrock of constitutional strength. Judicial activism is a way through which relief is provided to the disadvantaged and aggrieved citizens. Jack greenberg is a professor of law at columbia university and. Conclusion the judiciary has not acted in such a proactive role since independence but assumed such a role in a fullfledged manner only after the proclamation of emergency in 1975. Pil had already molded the state in to the instrument of socio economic change.
Jamie cassels judicial activism and public interest litigation in. Pil as an instrument of social change, conclusion and. The common law tradition conceives of courtroom litigation as an adversarial process where the onus is on the pleaders to shape the overall course of the. Social change, judicial activism, and the public interest lawyer. May 16, 2020 judicial activism can be coined as judicial creativity, judicial craftsmanship, judicial lawmaking, imaginative sharing of passion, look beyond the law, etc. It can declare a law or orders of the executive and legislative. The judiciary plays an important role in upholding and promoting the rights of citizens in a country. With the advent of public interest litigation pil in recent decades, 4.
Judiciary has become the centre of controversy, in the recent past, on account of the sudden me in the level of judicial intervention. A number of distinctive characteristics of pil can be identified, each of which is novel and in some cases contrary to the traditional legalist understanding of the judicial function. Judicial activism through a process known as public interest litigation pil has emerged as a powerful mechanism of social change in india. The true essence of judicial activism in the country thus can be determined by looking at the legal system of the country.
Unlike the case of public interest litigation in canada or the united states, the legal aidpublic interest movement in india has been almost entirely initi. Role of public interest litigation visavis judicial activism. Pdf environmental protection and judicial activism. Judicial activism under the indian constitution address by honble mr. I am indeed very grateful for the opportunity to speak about the evolution of judicial activism in the indian legal system. Several judges have reinterpreted court procedures and evolved what has. Oct 22, 20 judicial activism in india judicial activism is gaining prominence in the present days. Judicial activism in india has, in several key cases, found statedirected economic development ineffective and a failure, then interpreted laws and issued directives that encourage greater competition and free market to reduce environmental pollution. The tryst with destiny that commenced for india as an independent nation, sixty years back, has travelled several chapters of struggle, toil and triumph. Pil today offers such a paradigm which locates the content of informal justice without the formal legal system. Judicial activism and overreach, conference shree venkaiah naidu kesavanand bharti case lily thomas case kashinath mahajan case how to prepare for upsc onl.
Justice bhagwati will become chief jus tice of the supreme court of india in july of 1985. In this video lecture, amit kataria brings you indian polity topics from m laxmikanth. What is the role of pil and judicial activism in promoting social justices. Conclusion the judiciary has not acted in such a proactive role since independence but assumed such a role in a fullfledged manner only after the.
Impact of judicial activism on government law corner. Judicial activism and public interest litigation in india by pritam. Historical development of the concept of judicial activism the concept judicial activism is pronounced much more in the scholastic realm of legal and political studies. Pakistan has been experiencing unprecedented wave of judicial activism since 2006. It is usually through the pil, but the supreme court from time to time has given directions, passed writs and issued orders to redress the injustice either on the request or by its own. Judicial activism is seen as a success in the liberalization of access to justice and provides assistance to disadvantaged groups.
A critical analysis on judicial activism and overreach doi. This judgement, according to some groups, was an act of judicial activism as these are the tasks of the legislature not the judiciary. The worldwide debate on judicial activism the term judicial activism, finds its origin in an article titled the supreme court. Over the years the indian judiciary has always been hailed as an activist judiciary.
Non anglosaxon jurisdiction directs courts to transcend the traditional judicial function of adjudication and provide remedies for social wrongs. The idea of pil came from actiopopular is of the rome jurisprudence which allowed court. Gupta vs union of india case firmly established the validity of the public interest litigation. Judicial powers, selfrestraint, selfindulgent, public interest litigation introduction now a day, judicial activism has touched almost each and every sphere of life ranges from human rights issues to maintenance of roads. In many cases judicial activism has caused undue interference in the political and social arena, overdependence on the. In a country like india, the judiciary works on the principle of complying with the ideas and intentions of lawmakers that existed while framing an. Public interest litigation, indian constitution, fundamental rights, directive principles of state policy, social action litigation, courts and democracy, judicial activism, misuse, frivolous litigation.
Another area of judicial activism is regarding good governance and accountability of public authorities. The word litigation means a legal action including all proceedings therein, initiated in a court of law with the purpose of enforcing a right or seeking a remedy. The phrase judicial activism carries more than one connotation. Judicial activism and pil corporate law firms in chennai. Under article 32, violation of a fundamental right must first be shown before the supreme court can directly entertain a pil matter. Until the emergence of pil, justice was a remote reality for the socially and economically backward sections of society. We will email your chosen dissertation in pdf format within 24 hours. What is the role of judicial activism to relax the rule of locus standi in pil.
This type of litigation was innovated by judges to provide equal access to the unprivileged section of the society. Nov 14, 2016 judicial activism relies on the idea that the judges undertake the character of an independent policy makers or independent trustees or representatives on behalf of the entire society, and they are further inclined to go beyond their traditional role as interpreters of the constitution and laws. Judicial activism and public interest litigation heinonline. Judicial activism and public interest litigation in india by. This is the very first case, in which the supreme court took a step above the legislation. India air 1981 sc 344 and the idea of public interest litigation blossomed in s. Public interest litigation means litigation in the interest of public entered judicial process in 1970. Judicial activism has emerged as a powerful mechanism of social change in india. The concept of pil which has been and is being fostered by judicial activism has been an increasingly important one setting up valuables and respectable records, especially in the erena of constitutional and legal treatment for unrepresentative and underrepresented. Judicial activism in the area of human rights has been facilitated in a large measure by pil. To study the role of pil in environment protection 5. Public interest litigation and the judicial activism lawpage. Moreover, the significance of public interest litigation cannot.
Judicial activism and public interest litigation raijmr. Judicial activism has come into light in recent times when supreme court has tried to ensure that the administration of the country does not suffer because of the negligence on the part of the executive and the legislature. Besides other rights, life and personal liberty in article 21 have been given a very wide interpretation. Public interest litigation pil refers to litigation undertaken to secure public interest and demonstrates the availability of justice to sociallydisadvantaged parties and was introduced by justice p. There are various methods of judicial activism that followed in india. It is the power of judiciary to proclaim any law annulled and unconstitutional. Notable forms of judicial activism pil expansion of scope of f. Role of judiciary in development of environmental jurisprudence professor upendra baxi, who has often supported the judicial activism in india, has also said that the supreme court of india has often become.
Essay judicial activism in india gr8ambitionz prepare. Judicial activism judicial activism is a concept that originated in the us in 1947. It now dominates the public perception of the supreme court. Public interest litigation pil and judicial activism. Aug 05, 2018 through public interest litigation, any public or person can seek remedy on behalf of the oppressed class by introducing a pil. The traditional rule of locus standi the right to file a petition in a court was that judicial remedy could. Jan 31, 2020 judicial activism is a laymans term for the role of judiciary in initiating the policies to dispense justice. It was an idea that was in the making for some time before its vigorous growth in the early eighties. The golak nath case is an example of judicial activism. To study the problems regarding the exercise of judicial activism through pil. Blacks law dictionary defines judicial activism as a philosophy of judicial decisionmaking whereby judges allow their personal views about public policy, among other factors, to guide their decisions. Judicial activism in india essay essay on judicial. On the other hand, some important pil like caste survey before deciding reservation quota were found unworthy.
Insights mind maps upsc ias exam preparation insights ias. Balakrishnan, chief justice of india trinity college dublin, ireland october 14, 2009 ladies and gentlemen. The judiciary, led by the supreme court, became an active participant in the dispensing of social justice and increased its relevance to the nation in a manner not envisaged by the makers of the constitution. To study relation between pil and judicial activism and emergence of pil in india. Social change, judicial activism, and the public interest. Pil and judicial activism in india judicial activism ban on smoking in public places protection against inhuman treatment in jail child welfare. The first landmark case in this regard was the case of marbury v. Judicial activism in india essay essay on judicial activism. Law dissertations public interest litigation supreme. Public interest litigation the term public interest means the larger interests of the public, general welfare and interest of the masses. This article first describes the position of courts. Judicial activism is the rendering of decisions, which are in tune with the temper and tempo of the times. Through setbacks and achievements, tragedies and celebrations.
The active role of the judiciary in upholding the rights of citizens and preserving. Public interest litigation pil as it has developed in recent years marks a signi. Judicial activism to public interest litigation ipleaders. The phenomenon that bears testimony to this label is. The enactment of the canadian charter of rights and. Various high courts hereinafter referred to as higher judiciary have become increasingly sensitive and devoted their attention towards environmental protection, particularly pollution due to. Oct 25, 2019 the phrase judicial activism was first coined by the american historian, arthur m. Pil and judicial activism in india judicial activism. Equating pil with judicial activism is a misconception it is equated with pil mainly because it is the most convenient vehicle for bringing public grievances before courts and because the courts orders in pils are farreaching and some times sensational. Sep 17, 2018 judicial activism has come into light in recent times when supreme court has tried to ensure that the administration of the country does not suffer because of the negligence on the part of the executive and the legislature. Schlesinger viewed judicial activism as a measure to. Guest article judicial activism in india by vishal gupta. Public interest litigation has historically been an innovative judicial procedure for enhancing the social and economic rights of disadvantaged and marginalized groups in india. Judicial activism and public interest litigation in india.
Unlike the case of public interest litigation in canada or the united states, the legal aidpublic interest. Judicial activism and public interest litigation in india researchgate. From 1979, the judiciary led by the supreme court in. Judicial activism is providing a base for policy making in competition with the legislature and executive. What are judicial activism and overreach in hindi pil.
Public interest litigation in nations other than the u. The doctrine of separation of powers was propounded by the french. Due to the confusion following the carping comments of the supreme court on judicial activism, on the tendency of judiciary to encroach into the powers of the legislature and the executive, a two judge bench of the apex court declined further hearing of a matter relating to rehabilitation of victims of flesh trade and referred the 2004 pil to a. Public interest litigation pil and judicial activism what. Feb 20, 20 this paper traces the origin and development of pil in india and seeks to analyze how pil came to india as a result of judicial activism of some judges and their initiative to deliver social justice in an effective manner. Judicial activism and public interest litigation in. In the form of public interest litigation pil, citizens are getting access to justice. The expansion within constitutional fundamental rights has broadened the scope of public interest litigation pil in almost every sphere of life. Constitution, judicial activism, public interest litigation pil, supreme court in india. This is the power of the judiciary to interpret the constitution. To study the role of judicial activism on environment jurisprudence in india 4.
1618 277 1031 123 403 1756 533 703 1866 1087 813 888 1341 1152 1017 1772 1275 1103 644 1650 1152 1680 814